Comparing Christian McCaffrey vs. Jonathan Taylor

Showing consensus odds · Scoring: Standard / Rating strategy: 0.5

Washington Commanders at San Francisco 49ers · Oct 20, 2026, 12:15 AM UTC

Comparison settings
ConservativeBalancedAggressive

Higher Start/Sit Ratings mean stronger recommendations, not projected fantasy points. Compare ratings with the same scoring, strategy and bookmaker settings. How ratings work

Headshot of Christian McCaffrey

Christian McCaffrey

RB - SF

Start/Sit Rating

20.98

Excellent

Anytime TD Scorer

Yes
-272 (73.1%)

Receiving Yards

Over
39.83 (-114)
Under
39.83 (-113)

Receptions

Over
4.5 (-131)
Under
4.5 (-34)

Rushing + Receiving Yards

Over
104.5 (-113)
Under
104.5 (-115)

Rushing Yards

Over
59.17 (-114)
Under
59.17 (-114)
Headshot of Jonathan Taylor
-3.10

Jonathan Taylor

RB - IND

Start/Sit Rating

17.88

Good

Anytime TD Scorer

Yes
-270 (73.0%)

Receiving Yards

Over
17.83 (-115)-22.0
Under
17.83 (-112)-22.0

Receptions

Over
2.5 (-134)-2.0
Under
2.5 (+36)-2.0

Rushing + Receiving Yards

Over
111.17 (-114)+6.7
Under
111.17 (-114)+6.7

Rushing Yards

Over
89.17 (-114)+30.0
Under
89.17 (-114)+30.0
Christian McCaffrey
Home
ML: -416
Sprd: -7.5
Tot: 50.5
Win: 80.6%
Jonathan Taylor
Home
ML: -335
Sprd: -6.9
Tot: 44.3
Win: 77.0%

Compare another player

Find another matchup to compare.